In the wake of the brutal Jallianwala Bagh massacre of April 13, 1919, the British Secretary of State for India, Edwin Montagu, appointed a Disorders Inquiry Committee, universally known as the Hunter Commission. Chaired by Lord William Hunter, a former Scottish Solicitor-General, the committee was tasked with investigating the violent unrest in Punjab and evaluating the military response led by Brigadier-General Reginald Dyer.
The commission held extensive hearings in late 1919 and released its report on March 8, 1920. While the British majority and Indian minority members split on political interpretations of martial law, the unanimous conclusion severely censured Dyer's conduct. The report stated that Dyer had committed a grave error by opening fire without warning, continuing to shoot for ten minutes after the crowd began dispersing, and failing to provide medical aid to the wounded.
However, the commission stopped short of recommending criminal prosecution or a court-martial, concluding that Dyer had acted out of a mistaken sense of duty rather than personal malice. The British Army Adjutant-General subsequently relieved Dyer of his command and pensioned him off. For Indian nationalists, the absence of penal consequences exposed the systemic moral failure of British rule, directly motivating the Indian National Congress to abandon faith in colonial justice and launch mass civil disobedience.
Why it matters
The Hunter Commission report deepened the rift between Indian nationalists and the British Empire. By censuring Brigadier-General Dyer on technical grounds while absolving him of criminal liability, the British authorities displayed a glaring double standard of colonial justice. The mild penalty imposed on Dyer—resignation from the army without legal prosecution—outraged the Indian public, convincing Mahatma Gandhi and moderate nationalists that constitutional petitions were futile. This official whitewash transformed moderate reformers into active revolutionaries and catalyzed the Non-Cooperation Movement.
Interesting fact
The three Indian members of the Hunter Commission—Sir Chimanlal Harilal Setalvad, Pandit Jagat Narayan, and Sultan Ahmed Khan—authored a scathing minority dissent report that explicitly condemned Michael O'Dwyer's administration and rejected martial law as unjustified.
People
- Lord William HunterChairman of the Disorders Inquiry Committee
- Brigadier-General Reginald DyerBritish officer responsible for the Jallianwala Bagh shooting
- Sir Chimanlal Harilal SetalvadIndian nationalist lawyer and member of the Hunter Commission
- Edwin MontaguBritish Secretary of State for India who ordered the inquiry
Quotes
"He committed a grave error in firing upon the crowd without giving them an opportunity to disperse, and continuing to fire until his ammunition was exhausted."
"I thought it my duty to fire on them, and to fire well... I was going to give them a lesson."
Gallery
Location
Central Secretariat · New Delhi · India
Open in Google Maps